Ben Stein explores academia’s hostility towards Intelligent Design
I decided that it was time to see a documentary for my next review, so I took a trip to the Redbox and rented Ben Stein’s new work Expelled: No Intelligence Allowed. The film is narrated and documented completely by Ben Stein. He explores the foundations of intelligent design, misconceptions in Darwinist Theory that are taught in schools, and the overall hostility the academic world has towards even the slightest exploration of intelligent design.
There were several points the film presented. Stein is an obvious proponent of intelligent design, and throughout the course of the film, tries to have staunch opponents of intelligent design, such as Richard Dawkins, prove that intelligent design must be wrong. Obviously, none of these self-proclaimed atheists can prove that the theory must be incorrect. Stein also interviews several academics who claim to have been fired or not been given tenure due to their beliefs of intelligent design or even just begging the question of the issue. Stein wants to know why the idea is just completely thrown away in most aspects of the academic world without even a little exploration.
I believe Mr Stein achieved many of his goals in the film. First, it contrasts Intelligent Design from Literal Biblical Analysis, which it is often misconstrued to be. Second, he shows that there is a definite absence of freedom of thought in the academic world that is potentially poisoning to learning environments. Third, he shows how unreasonable some of the staunch academic atheists like Mr Dawkins can be on this issue and that they really have no reason to completely dismiss these ideas as irretrievably wrong.
Contrarily, I thing this film may have been a little too ambitious. I would’ve liked to have heard more about one of the points he made – the connection between Darwinism and Nazism. His argument on this topic was much weaker than some of the others, and don’t think that it had to be; he seemed to be on to something, and I think it would’ve been a potentially scandalous connection – and I love drama.
It is a shame that because this movie has a conservative flavor, it will be outright rejected by the Hollywood elite, and, as such, not up for any kind of reward; this film did not appear on the short list the Academy recently released for potential nominees for Best Documentary Feature. That’s a shocker!
Despite not being the most organized documentary I’ve seen, it was certainly interesting, and Ben Stein’s dry monotonous humor never seizes to amaze me. As such, I give it a B+.